The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2000/Broken Cedars
    Broken Cedars — Forever cover

    Broken Cedars

    Forever

    (2000)

    Reviewed by Justin W. Jones

    DiscogsBandcamp
    Label Screaming Giant RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2000
    melodic hardcorepop punkskate punk

    Broken + Cedars= three piece punk. But this time there's a catch...it has melody. Fast, furious, and melodic with a spiritual edge. Broken Cedars' debut album will ensure them a spot up there with the other melodic speed punk groups like Slick Shoes and Sick of Change.

    What will catch your attention is the great breaks they have in their mix. Right in the middle of a song they will switch off the distortion and you hear the same kind of grooves you used to hear in old school hardcore, usually during the sad part of the song, for a unique twist. It was unusual, but welcome to my ears.

    The only downside that I could think of was the vocals. There was a little bit too much of the nasal tone, almost as if the lead singer were trying to achieve the same sound as the lead singer of Slick Shoes, but then again imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. And on top of that, the production was subpar on the vocal tracks. If you could have put these in a better studio, then it would increase the value of the music.

    Basically, if you like melody in your carnage, get it.

    3 tocks

    Similar sounding releases

    1998MxPxLet It Happen2002NOFX45 or 46 Songs That Weren't Good Enough to Go on Our Other RecordsHangnailHangnail '981999Sick of ChangeIn Our Time of Need2005Strike AnywhereTo Live in Discontent2001DogwoodMatt Aragon

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2000

    2000AudityThe Language I Think In1999The AutumnsBoy With The Aluminum Stilts1999BeckMidnite Vultures2000JJ PlasencioJJ Plasencio2000Justin McRobertsFather2000SplatLife's Not Easy