The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998/Broomtree
    Broomtree — Broomtree cover

    Broomtree

    Broomtree

    (1997)

    Reviewed by Josh Spencer

    DiscogsYouTube
    Label Rustproof RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth1998
    alternative rockhard rockpop rockpower pop

    "Davia! You've come back to Dakoda Motor Co. and made a new record! Oh, I love you sooo much....wait a minute, you aren't Davia. What kind of sick joke is this.....?"

    Okay, maybe that was a bit harsh. But the truth is like that sometimes, and it really does seem that Broomtree has come along to halfway fill the Dakoda Motor Co. void, with vocalist Kylie sounding quite similar to Davia (with perhaps a little less confidence). The usual power pop alterna-guitars buzz along below her girlish singing, to make for good youth group ear candy. Miss Angie blows this away, though, if that tells you anything. One tune reminds me of Spooky Tuesday, another of Soulfood 76, yet a third of Juliana Hatfield (nah...not that good!). Sprinklings of funk sparkle every once in a while. The lyrics deal with emotions, relationships, looking to God, and so on, with plenty of hope and truth.

    A Broomtree sounds like it would be a unique thing to plant in one's CD collection, but I'd only recommend it for young ones just getting theirs started. Chick rock, yeah!

    2.5 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    7ball #16Reviewed by Nik BarnesHailing from Ohio, it's no surprise Broomtree has some things in common with neighbors Morella's Forest and Belly. Sometimes described as "hard and happy chick music" (as you'll hear for yourself on the record), the straight-ahead guitar rock and little-girl-lost vocals of Kylie Schlig charge through simple songs of faith and devotion. The main songwriter, as well as guitarist and vocalist,…The Phantom Tollbooth 1998Reviewed by Linda T. StonehockerShe calls it, "hard and happy chick music," and laughs. Kylie Schlig is female, but nobody's chick. Kylie Schlig is the real deal. A poet and guitar student long before she decided to head up a rock 'n roll band, she wasn't manufactured or packaged by anyone besides herself, and her redeemer. She's assembled a tight, loud four-piece to flood her songs with a buzz so solid you can lean on it in…

    Similar sounding releases

    1999Pep SquadYreka Bakery2000SundryThe Toughest No-Brainer Yet1998Eric ChampionNaturalDakoda Motor CompanyRailroad1999Room Full of WaltersEl Grande2002The ZiggensThe Ziggens

    More from Broomtree

    1999Transparent

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1998

    1997Havalina Rail Co.Russian Lullabies1998Set On EdgeSod Pottage1998Various ArtistsAnakin1998FrodusConglomerate International1998Jaci VelasquezJaci Velasquez1997SelfmindeadSelfmindead