The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1999/Five Iron Frenzy
    Five Iron Frenzy — Quantity Is Job 1 cover

    Five Iron Frenzy

    Quantity Is Job 1

    (1998)

    Reviewed by Aaron Bell

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label 5 Minute WalkThe Phantom Tollbooth1999
    skaska punk

    In an effort to single-handedly flood the market, Five Iron Frenzy has put on a new disc with their brand of quality music, solid lyrics, and edgy sarcastic humor. A member of the big three Christian ska bands (along with the Insyderz and Supertones), Five Iron Frenzy continues to make music that is comparable to many of its secular counterparts in quality and ability. This album shows some maturing, but for fans of the first two albums there is not too much maturing so they should still love it.

    Starting off the disc with a track entitled "My Evil Plan to Save the World," the seven guys and a girl of Five Iron Frenzy show they still know how to have a good time. The band also has some fun with the very short, loud, and fast hardcore punk song "When I Go Out."

    One of the most fun pieces is a tribute to what happens when you combine success, the Internet, and some crazy rumors. "The Untimely Death of Brad" talks about the rumors of the loss of trumpeter Brad Dunham:

    I might stretch the truth,
    May be a little lie,
    There was a boy named Brad,
    He played trumpet,
    And he died,
    Too young for him to cease,
    Why? We haven't got a clue,
    It's on the internet,
    So then it must be true.

    Lead vocalist Reese Roper sings these words very much tongue in cheek, and the band comes through again on a fun tune. The band also succeeds in getting the point across to some overzealous fans to watch out because everything you read about the group or its members is not necessarily true.

    Five Iron Frenzy also can be serious with great tracks such as "All That is Good" and "Dandelions." "Dandelions" looks at the idea of God seeing us as beautiful when in reality we are pretty much just weeds:

    Lord, search my heart,
    Create in me something clean,
    Dandelions,
    You see flowers in these weeds

    All this excitement plus throw in a cover of Electric Light Orchestra's "Sweet Talkin' Woman" and a rock opera about pants that has to be heard to truly be understood, and you have a great album from one of the best young bands in music.

    4 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    HM Magazine #75Reviewed by Brian Vincent McGovernAlways susceptible to snappy titles and cool music, the band is still loaded to the gills with energy, as is evidenced by their rigorous touring schedule and the wild enthusiasm displayed at each show. This EP finds the band with increased tightness and more texture and variety in the horns. Lyrically, the band is still clever, but pointed. Songs like "One Girl Army" are such great songs in…The Lighthouse Unsorted 1999Reviewed by Rhonda EudalyFive Iron Frenzy is back with the follow-up to Our Newest Album Ever!. Quantity Is Job 1 is perhaps misnamed, as the band has produced a quality project that's a bit short on quantity, with only eight real tracks and one rock opera. But fear not, Five Iron fans - it is enough. For those who still aren't certain about the whole ska thing, this is a great project to cut your teeth on. Five Iron…Exit Zine 1999Reviewed by James M. BranumAfter listening to Five Iron Frenzy's last album (Our Newest Album Ever) for the umpteenth time I thought, "They will never top this." And while they didn't top that feat of ska-manship, they come pretty darn close in their latest release, Quantity Is Job 1. The guys (and one gal) of FIF have continued to wow and amaze their multitude of skanking fans with their original lyrics and phenomenal…ReAL Magazine 1998Reviewed by Kevin D. HendricksOnly Five Iron Frenzy would release a 16 track EP and call it Quantity is Job 1. Thankfully it comes at the price of an EP. Of those 16 songs, you get six legit songs and a bunch of... well, Five Iron being themselves. Included in the goofiness is the eight-part rock opera, "These Are Not My Pants." Of the legitimate songs, there's not a loser in the bunch. Goofiness starts things off with "My…

    Similar sounding releases

    2002ApologetiXGrace Period200010 Fingers CountingUndeserved Love2003Hill Valley Preservation SocietyErased...From Existence1999Cesar RosasSoul Disguise2001The DingeesThe Crucial Conspiracy1999The PietastersAwesome Mix Tape #6

    More from Five Iron Frenzy

    1996It's Funny... but not very creative.2003Cheeses...2000All the Hype That Money Can Buy1996Upbeats and Beatdowns2003The End Is Here1997Our Newest Album Ever!

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1999

    1999Hokus PickSuper Duper1998Vigilantes of LoveFree For Good1999Various ArtistsSongs from The Book1998Smalltown PoetsListen Closely1998LedfootLedfoot1998PoundhoundMassive Grooves From the Electric Church of Psychofunkadelic Grungalism Rock Music