The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2001/Huddle
    Huddle — Basement Carnival cover

    Huddle

    Basement Carnival

    (2001)

    Reviewed by Brian A. Smith

    Label independentThe Phantom Tollbooth2001
    indie rockpop rock

    Independent band Huddle consists of three brothers, Bryon, Nolan, and Danny Rossi, and guitarist Nick Dean. Immediately upon reading the notes that came with the CD, I was jealous: these guys are still in college and have released their first CD!

    Some of the issues dealt with include frustration in trying to be faithful to God ("Again"), sex, peer pressure, and misinterpreted images of love ("Sweetest Day"), and the hurt caused by bad or uncaring parents ("Why Not Me?"). "Life Goes On" deals with the failure of a relationship and broken trust, but points out that there is One we can trust to always be there:

    While on these roads,
    we all feel pain
    But there is solace in one name
    and He won't say...goodbye

    At times the vocals here resemble Billy Corgan of Smashing Pumpkins, but without the whininess. Bryon Rossi's bass lines sound like the group Live in some songs. The overall tone of the album reminds me somewhat of the independent Minnesota band, Pegtop. At other points, the guitar work recalls west coast band dada. Huddle has done a good job here of blending different sounds and influences that make it difficult to pin down what their musical influence might be.

    Tinged with bittersweet lyrics, and some humor, Basement Carnival is a promising debut for this band. The most powerful track to me personally is "Why Not Me?," a tale of a child trying desperately to make his mother notice him:

    Please turn this car around
    I didn't mean to make you so mad
    Just tell me what I did wrong
    Please help me understand

    Is it so wrong of me
    Am I so selfish
    To want to finally see your smile
    to feel your breath and touch your skin
    Why don't you want your child?

    It goes on to show how neglected children, or children of divorce, or abusive situations try to reconcile themselves to their parents:

    I'll be good, And I'll be nice
    and when you say to settle down
    You won't have to ask me twice,
    Some things in life, you gotta keep
    And since you have to pick a few,
    Why not me?

    Another standout is the song "Kazoo Song," which features, you guess it, kazoos. Somehow, though, it works, blending the child's toy with the driving guitars, and use of pauses.

    Overall, this is an excellent beginning for a young band. It should be interesting to see if this is a one-off or the independent debut of a band that will become a collector's item when they hit it big.

    4 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    The Phantom Tollbooth 2001Reviewed by Chris MacIntoshAny band that starts off an album with backwards guitars and does it well has got my attention. Huddle consists of Nick Dean on guitar and backing vocals, Bryon Rossi on bass, keys, lead and backing vocals and kazoo, Danny Rossi on drums and percussion and Nolan Rossi on lead and backing vocals, guitars, harmonica and kazoo. This Michigan based group has a pleasant mid-western rock feel to the…

    More from Huddle

    2005Lush

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2001

    2000Sheryl StaceySheryl Stacey2001Mars IllRaw Material2001Over the RhineFilms for Radio2001Glass HarpStrings Attached2001The NobodysB-Sides2001Lust ControlWorst of Lust Control