The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2000/IndigoEcho
    IndigoEcho — One cover

    IndigoEcho

    One

    (1999)

    Reviewed by Alex Klages

    DiscogsApple MusicSpotify
    Label Room 3 RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2000
    britpopmodern rock

    "Take me higher, higher, higher with you..." cries the chorus of the opening track of this disc. This is what the album aims to do; take the listener along in a higher way; a way of deep thought and interesting guitar-based rock.

    By and large, it succeeds. The tunes are decently crafted, reminding the listener at times of Third Eye Blind, or the Gin Blossoms, and the lyrics are reasonable, sufficiently indirect to avoid triteness but with the Christian underpinnings that a person would expect.

    And this is its downfall; there's little surprising, exciting, or groundbreaking to this album. In fact, the mixing of a few songs put the vocals far enough in front of the music that they end up sounding detached, as though this is a solo singer in front of a generic backing band of which he has little pride. This clearly isn't the case, but the mix makes it sound that way. Fortunately, most songs on the album have a little more even balance to the mix. It's true that the vocals on an album need to be heard, but I'm sure that there is no need to push them so far out front, as on the first track, that there's nothing else that is emphasized.

    It's a fair album, but one that needs a little bit more to break out of the pack of guitar rock albums.

    3 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    The Phantom Tollbooth 2000Reviewed by James StewartIndigoEcho aren't short of attention at the moment. Having gotten their latest release stocked in HMV shops across their native Scotland and publicized its launch with a show in one of Edinburgh's biggest music outlets, they seem well poised to make the most of the next few months. The band have been toning up their musical muscles since their last release and have moved towards a Brit-rock sound…

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2000

    1999Jon BullerThe Sinner and the Saint2000Cloud2GroundThe Gate Beautiful1999Phil KeaggyMusic to Paint By - Splash2000PhatfishPurple Through the Fishtank2000Elementary PenguinNo. 1 With A Bullet2000AudityThe Language I Think In