The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2005/LSU
    LSU — Dogfish Jones cover

    LSU

    Dogfish Jones

    (1998)

    Reviewed by Greg Adams

    DiscogsBandcamp
    Label Platinum RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2005
    alternative rockpsychedelic rock

    At the end of his acoustic version of "Seashell Sally" on the CD Live in Nash-Vegas, alterna-pioneer Michael Knott proclaims, "That's off Dogfish Jones--you can't buy that anywhere!" Well, Homeric rock opera fans, now you can, thanks to a painstakingly faithful reissue by Retroactive Records.

    Knott's timeless maritime characters Dogfish Jones, Barnacle Bob, Mercy Maid, and, yes, Seashell Sally are all dusted off and digitally remastered on this limited edition Retroactive reissue. With accurate packaging (including a nice excerpt from Mark Allan Powell's Encyclopedia of Contemporary Christian Music about Knott and Dogfish Jones) and enhanced audio clarity, the newly restored Dogfish Jones is no half-hearted, landlubberly knock-off, as some Knott reissues have been (most of the M8 efforts come to mind...especially the tragically misguided reanimation of Wakin' Up The Dead).

    Repeated play-and-flips between the original 1998 Light Records Dogfish Jones release and the reissue reveal no glaring discrepancies, except that (aside from a slight airy hiss on "Greensea Island") the 2005 version sounds much more pleasing: Knott's intricately intertwined, layered vocals, subversive screams, powerful guitars and shimmering acoustic additions are much more "up front" in the new mix. Gene Eugene's fantastic "B-movie" B-3 organ parts take center stage, as well, which is justifiable, since Knott has cited Eugene as perhaps the element that makes this album truly outstanding. Other guest musicians from Knott's endless arsenal of talented friends include Chuck Cummings and Andrew Carter (his Aunt Bettys bandmates) on drums and guitar, respectively, Jeff Elbel (of Ping/Marathon Records fame) on bass, and even Knott's dad, Howard Knott, on vocals. (Knott, Sr., lends his gravelly, weathered voice to the sailor anthems "Storm At Sea" and "The Boyos.")

    Retroactive Records should be commended for resurrecting this classic, which is one of Knott's three "rock operas" (L.S.Underground's The Grape Prophet and Knott's solo record Fluid are of the same ilk). Hopefully Retroactive Records' quest to liberate fine albums from obscurity will continue. Suggested search-and-rescue missions: the aforementioned Grape Prophet, The Violet Burning's Strength, and Gordon Gano's mid-1980's gospel side-project The Mercy Seat.

    RIYL: Jane's Addiction, David Bowie, The Choir, Cush, The Violet Burning

    Other coverage for this album

    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998Reviewed by Steven S. BaldwinMichael Knott: mayhem magnet or mostly misunderstood? Maybe to some extent both, but the former by circumstance not choice. He does seem to crave both attention and acceptance. Wild rumors abound, most of which are historically unfounded, especially if careful attention is paid to his honest albums full of ironic wit, faith-filled encouragements, and stark observations of life at once joyous and…7ball #14Reviewed by Brad CavinessEven Mike Knott's most ardent supporters will usually admit that his work is uneven. And that's the case with Knott's new LSU project, Dogfish Jones. When given the opportunity to do this record, he could have taken the money and delivered an armload of unused Aunt Bettys demos. Instead, he delivered a Homeric tale told through Irish sailing songs filtered through psychedelic rock. Dogfish Jones…

    Similar sounding releases

    2004The FramesSet List1994RadioheadMy Iron Lung2003CursiveThe Ugly Organ2004They Sang As They SlewGet Well1998Pearl JamYield2001PushcarApartment D

    More from L.S. Underground

    1991This Is the Healing1994Grace Shaker1999Definitive Collection

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2005

    2004Lost and FoundSpeedwood Hymns2004The Black SpoonsMy Dear Radium2003Jon BauerLife of Worship2004The Sound GalleryDesigned for Reading2005Dope SmoothieGo Strike1972Glass HarpIt Makes Me Glad