The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998/Maire Brennan
    Maire Brennan — Perfect Time cover

    Maire Brennan

    Perfect Time

    (1998)

    Reviewed by Dave Landsel

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Word RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth1998
    celticfolkworship

    While the platinum-sellers Clannad certainly cannot be called obscure, somehow the Irish pop/folk pioneers never came to enjoy the name recognition of Enya, whom everyone knows as a purveyor of those ethereal, spiritually flavored, Celtic pop treats which have found their way onto radio, into film soundtracks, commercials, and into the hearts of music-lovers world wide. The stuff of legends.

    Maire Brennan, long time frontwoman of Clannad, and sister to the diva, has put quite some effort forth heretofore towards solo work, but only recently did she choose to focus on her (somewhat private) faith, with her Word Records release, Perfect Time. When asked what led her in this direction, Brennan speaks of her faith, and her long-term dilemma over Clannad's somewhat dubious title of "New Age." Never feeling particularly driven to record a Christian record, she pursued her career with the band, a career full of twists, turns and surprises. It was only recently that she was approached by her American manager about a gospel album. Perfect Time is the result of that meeting.

    The album contains a lot of great traditional numbers, many sung entirely in Maire's native tongue, Gaelic. Curiously, naggingly so, many of them, such as the title track itself, seem a little "dumbed down," shall we say? What makes much of the music in the genre so appealing is the mystery of it all -- am I stretching critical limits in assuming that the folks over at Word felt they needed to slip a little of the Point of Grace (see track 5) vibe into the mix in order to sell records at a brisker pace? Perhaps they believed that an audience weaned on Cindy Morgan would be unable to fathom the mystery of a more in-depth project? Pity thus, because there's nothing better than an authentic piece of ethnic artistry, and what we seem to have here is a mix of American praise and worship, ethereal pop, and traditional Irish musicianship.

    Whatever the case may be with that, there's much to love, such as the instrumental "Doon Well," a haunting, flowingly elegant number which recalls the greenery of the British Isles, and while a song on a Maire Brennan album titled "The Big Rock" seems as great a faux pas as introducing electric guitar into a Bach chorale, the catchy opener seems fresh, airy and full of life and hope. The closing instrumental is to be enjoyed as well. To sum it up, the album is enjoyable, however, here's hoping that if her career within the CCM field is to continue, she'll give us more of the creative music she's so good at, (such as tracks like "Whispered Words" on her solo album Misty Eyed Adventures) and a little less white fluff.

    If you're unfamiliar with the particular genre, this could be a good introduction to the world of modern Celtic music. Brennan has taken her own folk heritage, prevalent in the music of Clannad, taken some of the ethereality of her sister's, and added some contemporary stylings to create an enjoyable, inspirational piece of work -- congratulations to the artist. However, if it's original creations, or just plain old traditional music you're looking for, you're better off picking through your Clannad collections.

    Other coverage for this album

    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998Reviewed by James StewartThere has been quite a bit of coverage of this album in the Christian press here in Britain. This is probably because Maire is the singer from Clannad as well as Enya's sister. This, her third solo album, is her first in the Christian marketplace and follows her appearance on Iona's Journey Into The Morn. The vocals kick in immediately as the album opens, which I find disconcerting. Maire has a…

    Similar sounding releases

    1996IonaJourney Into The Morn1998Eden's BridgeCeltic Worship1997Genie and Troy NilssonWhisper1995Adrian SnellCity of Peace2001Mary-KathrynOne Spirit2000Sheila WalshBlue Waters

    More from Maire Brennan

    2001New Irish Hymns1999Whisper to the Wild Water

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1998

    1995Rob MathesWilliam the Angel1998Sonik Boom of LoveA Love Supreme1998Various ArtistsDownstream: A WeatherVane Compilation1998Blame LucyGong Show1975John FaheyChristmas with John Fahey Volume II1997CreedMy Own Prison