The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    Opus 2002/Melinda Gidaly
    Melinda Gidaly — This Mortal Lust cover

    Melinda Gidaly

    This Mortal Lust

    (2002)

    Reviewed by Anna Maria Stjärnell

    Discogs
    Label independentOpus2002
    lo-fisinger-songwriter

    Originally published at Opus →

    Melinda Gidaly's album consists of lo-fi, witty folk sung with an alarming candour. Gidaly sings some pretty amazing lyrics here. The forthright "Memory of Lust" states "Oh, the memory of lust/My hips holding more than I can trust."

    "You:Desert, Not Deserted" is quietly eerie with its unnerving vocal harmonies. In "Every Heart a Home" she sings "Today I broke the sound barrier with my hysteria." The song is still pretty restrained, but it shivers with pent up emotion.

    Gidaly's not really like anyone else, but here she echoes Liz Phair. She has the same sassy brand of honesty about her. The closing song "Spanakopita" is a partly spoken, partly sung epic that's very impressive.

    This album is a beautiful and daring thing. I hope Gidaly makes many more like it.

    Also in Opus 2002

    2002Broken SpindlesBroken Spindles2001LanternaElm Street1983Violent FemmesViolent Femmes2002Pedro the LionControl2002Counting CrowsHard Candy2002Canary / Under The RedThe Scissors & Blue Series: 4 of 6