The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2005/Nightwish
    Nightwish — Once cover

    Nightwish

    Once

    (2004)

    Reviewed by Dan Singleton

    DiscogsBandcampApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Roadrunner RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2005
    gothic metalpower metalsymphonic metal

    It's not often that a song comes on the radio as I'm driving down the highway, tells me it's Rick James, and nearly smacks me right off the road. The last time I heard a song that good on the radio for the first time was Creed's My Own Prison eight years ago. Well, it's happened again.

    Nightwish's "Nemo" (track three on this album) had me describing the song and asking my friends and contacts if they knew who recorded it for nearly a week before I identified it and promptly purchased the album.

    "Nemo" begins with subdued pulse-pounding that aptly builds into heavy guitars and sweet female vocals. If you like lulls and build-ups closing with electric guitar soloing, you'll enjoy this song as much as I do.

    Nightwish takes Canterbury prog into thick distorted speed metal dimensions while retaining classic medieval chord progressions. More than anyone else, they resemble Blind Guardian--but with more frequent orchestral accompaniment and beautiful female vocals from Tarja Turunen. Tarja's Celtic trills initially had me thinking of an Irish band instead of a Finnish one. Yeah, I know. I should have known better since all progressive metal bands are Scandinavian.

    Most of the songs have beautiful enigmatic lyrics. Some of the time, their message sounds pagan (and by that I mean actual pagan, not just non-Christian), but I found it easy to connect with their idealism, for example in "Dark Chest of Wonders:"

    Faith brought me here
    It's time to cut the rope and fly
    Fly to a dream
    Far across the sea
    All the burdens gone
    Open the chest once more
    Dark chest of wonders
    Seen through the eyes
    Of the one with pure heart
    Once so long ago

    The lyrical themes are classic goth, and they are very nicely done. The entire album is above average. Most of their songs are Celtic ballads wrapped in the muscles of speed metal. I was especially pleased to find another tune to equal "Nemo." That being the previously mentioned lead track, "Dark Chest of Wonders." Every time you think you've heard the chorus, you realize it was just a bridge to an even better chorus. This works for a great symphonic effect and this song isn't the only time they use it. Once earns a belated #4 spot on my Top Ten Albums of 2004 list. I can't wait to start obtaining this band's back catalog.

    4.5 tocks

    Similar sounding releases

    2003Balance of PowerHeathen Machine2004EvergreyThe Inner Circle1999MetallicaS&M2003HarmonyDreaming Awake1998TeramazeTears to Dust2005Stream of PassionEmbrace the Storm

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2005

    2004Josh DoyleThe End of Fear2004SeedsRooted2005The Hold SteadySeparation Sunday2005Lucas AllenMostly Hymns2004Forgiven 5He Is Alive2005Foo FightersIn Your Honor