The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2002/Sparklehorse
    Sparklehorse — It's a Wonderful Life cover

    Sparklehorse

    It's a Wonderful Life

    (2001)

    Reviewed by Jon Singer

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Capitol RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2002
    experimentalindie rocklo-fi

    Many rock music fans are disenchanted with the lack of creativity in the current mainstream, and it's easy to see why. The alternative bands of the '80s and '90s have surfaced and become the norm, leaving a large void of creative and independent bands. Even once redeeming local "underground" acts too often are disappointing second-rate punk and metal bands.

    Experimentation in music has now become daring and risky. Outside of a select few R&B producers and artists, it's almost impossible to find an artist that experiments and succeeds. The latest release from Sparklehorse, It's a Wonderful Life, does just that.

    A heavily-textured melancholy landscape, It's a Wonderful Life is a very good album. It's filled with interwoven melodies and sounds that are fresh and relaxing. Lyrical and musical mystery tie the album together, and keep the listener curious. The album fails in only one aspect. With a little bit more pop sensibility, it could have been a landmark album and commercial success.

    The album starts with the title track, which introduces songwriter and singer Mark Linkous' soft and sweet vocals and his knack for odd and dark string arrangements. The next song, "Gold Day," brings it up a notch, adding a thumping bass line and a harder drum beat.

    The best song on the album is "Piano Fire," which has a much more upbeat approach and a great chorus. P.J. Harvey adds harmonies to the track and makes the song that much better.

    There are no bad songs on It's a Wonderful Life, yet there are some that seem too slow, and challenge the listener's patience. Still, each track has a solid vocal melody and unique instrumentation. There are no standard guitar, bass, and drum tracks. Every song is thickly layered and is a creative attempt at something bigger.

    It's a Wonderful Life shows that Sparklehorse has something to offer along with more successful experimental bands such as Radiohead, Moby, and the Flaming Lips. Sparklehorse likely won't share these bands' commercial success, but will definitely be a treat for those who discover them.

    3 tocks

    Similar sounding releases

    2004ElbowCast of Thousands2005LornaStatic Patterns and Souvenirs2003RadioheadHail to the Thief1998PJ HarveyIs This Desire?2000ThouPut Us in Tune2004PaatosKallocain

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2002

    2002Various ArtistsThe Wonderful Cross2002Rebecca St. JamesWorship God2002Fourth EstateDustbuster Demos2002Derek Lind12 Good Hours of Daylight2002Joy WilliamsBy Surprise2002All AccessThe Composites of Rock and Roll