The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2005/The Afters
    The Afters — I Wish We All Could Win cover

    The Afters

    I Wish We All Could Win

    (2005)

    Reviewed by Burton Wray

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label INO Records / EpicThe Phantom Tollbooth2005
    ccmpop rockpower pop

    There is a great deal of pressure on any group that is signed to INO Records. After all, this is the label of MercyMe, a group that enjoyed tremendous success a few years ago with their hit, "I Can Only Imagine." MercyMe hasn't had another hit on that level but they have still had a good bit of success. Any group signed to INO has to live in that shadow.

    On I Wish We All Could Win The Afters show that they can hold their own with about any group in CCM today.

    The album starts off with some nice guitars that don't quite get things rockin' but still set the stage for an interesting mid-tempo song. This track is made even more enjoyable by the vocals which have a unique sound to them. The second track, "Until the World" starts off sounding like a rock song, but slows down into another mid-tempo song. Things pick back up for the chorus which has the hardest rock sound yet on this album. The second verse continues with a tempo faster than the first. The project slows back down for "Someday" which starts off slow but has its faster moments. Those faster moments make the listener wish that the group would just break loose with one song that was full on rock since the group does so well at it. Instead the listener is treated to two straight ballads, "Love Leads Me On" and "All That I Am". These songs are quite enjoyable and some of the best rock ballads of the year but listeners are still left wishing for the group to just let loose and rock. "The Way You Are" picks things back up and may be one of the most rockin' tracks on the CD. The group dabbles with worship on "You" which could find its way into the praise and worship times of many youth groups.

    The group is one of the best to debut this year. They excel at mid-tempo rock and their ballads are quite enjoyable. They even offer a solid worship track that rock fans will enjoy. Some listeners will be left wishing that the group would have included a full-on rock song or two. Even without those songs, this album is still a solid debut from a group that people need to pay attention to.

    3.5 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    The Phantom Tollbooth 2005Reviewed by Brian A. SmithI Wish We All Could Win marks the major label debut of The Afters. The cover art, pictures of a tortoise and a hare, provides the hint as to the meaning of the title. The line is contained in the song "Someday," which laments the fact that not all who begin running the race will complete it.[ Per the band, the song Beautiful Love was written by Josh Havens for his wife. It is not a song about…

    Similar sounding releases

    2005KutlessStrong Tower2004Jimmy Eat WorldFutures2003DakonaPerfect Change2003The Juliana TheoryLove2005CartelChroma2005CircleslideUncommon Days

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2005

    2005New Brutalism2001-20032005Specimen 37The Endless Looping Game2004Relient KMmhmm2005John Michael TalbotThe Beautiful City (Single)2004QwiksandThe Fellowship of the Groove2004AmmiLaodicea