The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    Decapolis June 2005/A Day to Remember
    A Day to Remember — And Their Name Was Treason cover

    A Day to Remember

    And Their Name Was Treason

    (2005)

    Reviewed by John Durkee

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Indianola RecordsDecapolisJune 2005
    pop punkpost-hardcore

    Screamo is now cliche, and everyone knows it. There are ways that screamo bands add new elements to the style here and there, but for the most part, we all know what to expect from it. Poppy sung choruses, with screams howling over and catchy guitar lines, with a few breakdowns thrown in and perhaps a ballad for good measure. A Day to Remember (ADR) has all these elements, and while they are done well and have some of its own sound, it's been heard before. ADR's album And Their Name Was Treason has more hardcore elements and has an acoustic ballad, but overall it's a typical screamo album. The lyrics are also fairly typical, as they are either obsessive about a girl or just cliche. The perfect example is the song "You Had Me at Hello." I admit I do like the movie Jerry Maguire, but to whine the punch line of the movie over and over is just too cliche for the song to have any real meaning.

    The album opens with the obsessive sounding whispers of a stalker with a haunting piano and finally a dark voice saying, "I've been watching you," that goes into the first real song, "Heartless," the most hardcore song on the album and one of the more enjoyable tracks. The next song, "Your Way with Words is Through Silence," is easily the best song on the album with a great melody and a chorus that will stay in your head for the rest of the day. After this there are other bright spots, but for the most part it's downhill after track three.

    ADR may be cliche, and not add a lot to their genre; they do well with what they're doing and are better than most screamo bands. If you're a fan of the genre, this is well worth it, but otherwise And Their Name Was Treason is a bit forgettable.

    Similar sounding releases

    2005Chasing VictoryI Call This Abandonment2004The Prisoners DilemmaHandshakes, Hello and Goodbye2005Bear vs. SharkTerrorhawk2004Evergreen TerraceWriters Block2003KeelhaulSubject To Change Without Notice2005As Cities BurnSon, I Loved You At Your Darkest

    Also in Decapolis June 2005

    2005Starflyer 59Talking Voice vs. Singing Voice2005Stars Are Falling / SkylinesBlood & Ink Split Series Vol. 12005InnawayInnaway2005Some GirlsThe DNA Will Have It's Say2005SherwoodSing, But Keep Going2005Various ArtistsMonster-In-Law Soundtrack