The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2004/All Access

    All Access

    Secrets (6 songs)

    (2004)

    Reviewed by Brian A. Smith

    Label Moving in Stereo ProductionsThe Phantom Tollbooth2004
    alternative rockbritpopindie rock

    All Access seems to be moving in a new direction these days. Whereas in the past, they seemed to be channeling The Ramones and Green Day, Secrets shows them paralleling current favorites Radiohead and Coldplay, with a dash of the Strokes thrown in for good measure.

    "Baby" could be an outtake from the early days of "Creep"-era Radiohead, while "Nixon" is a hard driving, straight ahead rock tune in the mode of Audio Adrenaline. "Frying Tonight" features fuzzy guitars over an MC5-like vocal, while "Sarah Jane" veers into a Coldplay meets '70s' rock mixture. "Brian Wilson" is not a Barenaked Ladies cover.

    Usually when groups take a sudden shift in musical direction, the results aren't pretty (read: R.E.M. "Monster-era"), but All Access seems to make it work here. The EP leaves you wanting more, which is a good sign.

    3.5 tocks

    More from All Access

    Rock n' Roll Show2003A Million Miles (Single)1999[title unknown]200115 Charismatic Wonders2002The Composites of Rock and Roll2004Secrets (3 songs)

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2004

    2004Various ArtistsCCM Top 100/Greatest Songs in Christian Music, Volume 12003Summer BlanketCharm Wrestling2004MarillionMarbles2004Jerry GaskillCome Somewhere2004Front Seat FailureWill You Be There2004Various ArtistsGloria: A Christmas Celebration