The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2000/Beki Hemingway
    Beki Hemingway — Too Much Plenty cover

    Beki Hemingway

    Too Much Plenty

    (1999)

    Reviewed by James Stewart

    DiscogsBandcampApple MusicTIDALSpotify
    Label Salt Lady RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2000
    rockroots rock

    A good dose of touring can do wonders for an artist's recorded material. Having released the EP rinse. repeat shortly after her departure from This Train, Beki Hemingway has spent most of the past two years touring coffee shops, bookstores, and a variety of other venues. The result is that her debut full length has a much fuller, more assured sound than its predecessor without losing any of its humour or intimacy.

    The sound Hemingway has made her own shows clear relations with that of her former band, taking its cue from traditional rock and roll, but the rockabilly influence isn't nearly as pronounced as on This Train's recordings. Hemingway's vocals mesh naturally with both the music and the lyrics; she is clearly comfortable with the direction she's headed in.

    The lyrics are marked by their clarity and honesty. Whether taking the point of view of an eager child ("Make You Proud") or a cynical adult ("Sinsick"), Hemingway makes observations and confessions that will resonate with many. Her chief subject is relationships in the broadest sense of the term--one of the album's catchiest tunes, "Ft. Bragg", is concerned with a child's desire for respect from her peers--and she clearly has much to say.

    The sound can occasionally feel a little dry. "Sinsick"'s dryness fits the weary tone of the lyrics, but sometimes some more experimentation on the instrumental side--perhaps drawing more on the mandolin, accordion, and organ of Jonathan Rundman--might have given the album some useful variety.

    A significant step forward from its predecessor while leaving room for development, this album suggests that there is plenty to come from Beki Hemingway, and it'll be a long time before that's too much.

    4 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    The Phantom Tollbooth 2000Reviewed by Lisa ReidBeki Hemingway is back with a vengeance. Many have been eagerly awaiting her first full-length solo album since rinse. repeat. came out. Fans of either Hemingway or This Train will be thrilled with Too Much Plenty, and even those unfamiliar with either should consider giving this a listen. Too Much Plenty is a good, old-fashioned rock 'n' roll album, with lots of electric guitar, prominent drums,…

    Similar sounding releases

    1996Sarah MasenSarah Masen1996Erin O'DonnellA Scrapbook Of Sorts1994Charlie PeacockEverything That's on My Mind1997Rick EliasBlink2000PhatfishPurple Through the Fishtank1999LaRueLaRue

    More from Beki Hemingway

    2002Words for Loss for Words2004Tennesota2001Present

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2000

    2000David GrayLost Songs 95-982000Glenn Kaiser BandWinter Sun1999Various ArtistsOn the Brink of Infinity1998FonoGoesaroundcomesaround2000MustardTime Will Tell2000ZOEgirlZOEgirl