The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2004/Hidari Mae/Speed Not Steel
    Hidari Mae / Speed Not Steel — Hidari Mae / Speed Not Steel cover

    Hidari Mae/Speed Not Steel

    Hidari Mae / Speed Not Steel

    (2004)

    Reviewed by Brian A. Smith

    DiscogsTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Lujo RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2004
    ambientindie rockpost-rock

    Lujo Records takes a novel approach with this project -- two self-titled EPs on two different discs, yet packaged together. Hidari Mae recalls eighties gloomy new wavers such as Joy Division and the Smiths with the emo singer/songwriting style of Elliott Smith on their half of this project. The overall feel is plaintive and somber, most notably in "In the Name of Science" and "November, 1950."

    Speed Not Steal combines a lot of elements of bands I really like. They employ great use of harmonies a la Jellyfish with overdubbing of vocals that works extremely well. "Anything Isn't Everything" recalls the glory days of Ben Folds Five, while "I Lost the Battle" shows some Coldplay influence. In general, the band resembles another of my favorite indie projects from a few years ago, Wisconsin band Huddle. This half of the project definitely outshines the first.

    Hidari Mae: 3 tocks

    Speed Not Steel: 4 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    Decapolis July 2004Reviewed by Derek SkillingsDon't let the words "split ep" confuse you when referring to this Hidari Mae / Speed Not Steel split. This is not two bands sharing one ep with a couple of songs each, this split if you can even call it that is more like two completely separate albums sharing the same packaging. Each disc contains about 1/2 hour of material from the respective band, quite the deal for a split ep. As the two…

    Similar sounding releases

    2005The Silent TypeOf Writing / Of Violence2003Ester DrangInfinite Keys2005MeryllYou've Got Cousins2003Death Cab for CutieTransatlanticism2002Victory at SeaThe Good Night2004Liz JanesPoison & Snakes

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2004

    2004Michael PritzlHollow Songs2004Kelly ChapmanReal2003Erik Brandt / The Urban Hillbilly QuartetThe A-List (1995-2001)2004RosemariRosemari2003The WaifsUp All Night2004Kate CampbellSing Me Out