The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2005/Mae
    Mae — The Everglow cover

    Mae

    The Everglow

    (2005)

    Reviewed by Jonathan Avants

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Tooth & Nail RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2005
    emoindie rockpiano rockpop punk

    The Everglow follows the journey of a scruffy emo-lad through a storybook world. Donning a pilot-hat and toting his travel briefcase, he traverses oceans by riding atop friendly whales, finds companionship while walking in a wide candlelit field, trudges through nightmarish forests full of sinking mud pits, and faces crossroads with faded street names in an effort to reach his destination -- The Everglow.

    The CD is colored and slightly ridged to look and feel like a vinyl record; upon pressing play, slight deliberate record scratching in the background is heard to further denote the concept. An amiable female voice greets then politely instructs the listener, as a storyteller to a circle of eagerly listening children, to open the booklet and observe the water-colored/hand-drawn art accompanying each song to complete the experience. If The Everglow gets points for anything at all, it's how effectively the recording has realized the concept behind it-- the listener is immediately swept into the mood, and won't want to stop listening till the same female voice bids goodnight in the epilogue.

    The lyrics are passable by themselves, the musical pieces solid, and the concept easily discarded as pretentious when considered on its own; but when everything is mixed together, it's almost mind-blowing how inspired The Everglow feels. I can't see anyone imagining the journey portrayed in the booklet's artwork through the relatively ambiguous and simple lyrics themselves, nor does the artwork completely reveal what themes and situations are being portrayed without the musical accompaniment. With the images from the booklet stamped in the back of your mind, the songs really do provide a sense of storybook wonder and childhood marvel.

    That isn't to downplay Mae's songwriting, though; minus a couple tracks where the cheese gets the best of them, nearly all of the other tracks are solid, and some of them spectacular. "Painless" kills with an amazing chorus full of destructive guitar lines and slight prog-rock tones while "Anything" soars as high as a pop-rock ballad possibly can, with an incredible melody set to glistening guitars and ringing church bells. But it's how the songs tie into and are further exemplified by the other aspects of The Everglow disc that makes it such a commendable project.

    As alluded to in the lyrics and revealed fully in the artwork, the project's themes are universal. They are embodied in the story of the young, lone traveler through the hardships he faces and lessons he learns. The experiences of the traveler could be the band members' life story so-far, from searching for truth and fulfillment in the world, to eventually finding it in The Everglow. "Oh, and our hearts are on the Everglow, so just let go and fall into it."

    Yes, it's true that The Everglow is an emo-tinged pop-rock recording; it's just that it's a good one. It succeeds as an inspired and well-realized musical experience, a rare achievement in its field. Much greater than the sum of its parts, The Everglow deserves acclaim for achieving what it set out to be; an experience. It is, and one that shouldn't be missed.

    4.5 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    HM Magazine #114Reviewed by Jamie Lee RakeOn their sophomore longplayer, Mae transmutes emo’s romantic and fatalistic impulses into..a concept album? Yeah, or they just happen to have had a bunch of songs that worked well in a cyclical fashion and had a visual artist whup up some illustrations appropriate for a quite mature children’s book. In actuality, The Everglow is a triumph of thematic and structural ambition wed to heart-on-sleeve…Decapolis May 2005Reviewed by Justin CarrettaMae's The Everglow begins with a pleasant-sounding girl speaking over a musical bed of a repetitive piano melody, giving an instructional introduction on how to listen to the CD. She begins, "Hello, and welcome to The Everglow by Mae. You are now listening to the audio portion of the album. To complete your experience, please open the booklet that accompanies the compact disc. Good, you are now…

    Similar sounding releases

    2005Number One GunPromises for the Imperfect2005The AftersI Wish We All Could Win2004EmeryThe Weak's End2005Forever ChangedThe Need To Feel Alive2001Student RickSoundtrack for a Generation2003The Juliana TheoryLove

    More from Mae

    2005From Toledo to Tokyo (Video)2004Destination: B-Sides2003Destination: Beautiful

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2005

    2005The O.C. SupertonesFaith of a Child2005Night Is Invisible12005Delirious?Mission Bell2005Jess PillmoreReveal20053 the God Way3 the God Way2004FlameWhere There's Smoke...There's Fire