Almost from the very beginning, pop/rock's more memorable compositions have been a sure-fire combination of driving beats, catchy lyrics, and heartfelt vocals--all tied firmly to a sturdy melodic foundation. The Slate, the second EP from Pennsylvania's Movies with Heroes, succeeds nicely on several of these counts.
The frenetic, U2-inspired guitar runs and highly rhythmic vocal technique of "Dirty History" (I know you say you're feeling good/ I guess that's fine/ When you're not feeling so good/ How does your light shine?) combine for a particularly striking effect. Likewise, the stream-of-consciousness narration and dexterous use of irony on "Screenplay" mesh seamlessly with the song's languishing pace and emotive subject matter. And the album's standout track, "Hurricanes and Runways," weds the melodic, guitar-driven modern rock of Fono and the Foo Fighters to an unapologetically scathing viewpoint (This is what you'll see on the streets this fall/ What will the kids be wearing?/ Meanwhile the wind and waves are tearing up the coast/ Why are animal prints so big this spring?) to provide one of the more thought-provoking essays on materialism in recent recollection.
But, while the new EP exhibits a greater sense of melody and is more accessible than any of the group's previous efforts, the gains made by its instrumental and lyrical sections are largely muted by its weak vocal work. In fairness, Keith Wilson's lead vocals are both brisk and earnest and his quirky, David Byrne-like mannerisms instill each of the tracks with a significant portion of their infectious vitality. Nonetheless, it becomes increasingly difficult as the album wears on to push past the out-of-tune vocals that blanket the effort--with the task becoming all the more daunting when harmony vocals are added to the equation. That said, The Slate is still, by and large, a respectable piece of work that displays Movies with Heroes' ever-tightening grip on its distinctive brand of poignant, hook-heavy, modern rock. As infectious and insightful as the release is, a consistently stronger set of vocals would no doubt have served to elevate the fine second EP to truly impressive status.
3 tocks
Other coverage for this album
Decapolis 2001Reviewed by Tom BastianMovies with Heroes is one of the hardest working bands that I know. If you take a close listen to "The Slate", and a look into the history of this band you should begin to realize what I'm talking about. This five song EP really only disappointed me in one way and that's simply due to the fact that it's an EP. I was anxious to hear an entire album worth of material from these guys since changing…Decapolis 2001Reviewed by Nate BaileyLancaster Pennsylvania's own Movies with Heroes present their best release to date. Five songs of poppy melodic rock with well written songs and catchy harmonics. This isn't one of those CD's where the songs all blend together and you're left hoping the end is right around the corner. The music is mature and laid back because instead of playing to the audience, the band plays from the heart and…The Phantom Tollbooth 2001Reviewed by Ken MuellerThis is a decent disc from the Lancaster, PA band, but it paves no new ground. Most of the album is pretty standard indie rock/emo fare, not too far off from their earlier work. Fans of emo will recognize, at once, the traditional emo vocals and guitars. The first song, "Hurricanes and Runaways" juxtaposes Hurricane Floyd with perceptions of the fashion world, pointing out the absurdity of our…The Phantom Tollbooth 2001Reviewed by Chris MacIntoshThis five song ep is my introduction to the Pennsylvania based group that goes by the name "Movies With Heroes." The quartet consists of Keith Wilson on vocals, guitars and lyrics, Jeff Royer on bass guitar and vocals, John Donahue on guitar, french horn and keyboard and Jeremy E. Bentley on drums. Although short in length, this disc is very impressive in quality and content. Production was…Similar sounding releases
2000Sleater-KinneyAll Hands on the Bad One
2001The StrokesIs This It
2003The ConstantinesShine a Light
2002The GhostThis is a Hospital
1999BeezewaxSouth of Boredom
2003The Rocket SummerCalendar Days
