Smalltown Poets

Item: It's Later Than It's Ever Been
Author: Bert Gangl

It's Later Than It's Ever Been

(2004)

Reviewed by Bert Gangl

Discogs Bandcamp Apple Music TIDAL Amazon Music Spotify YouTube Music

Label BEC RecordingsThe Phantom Tollbooth2005

acoustic rock ccm pop rock

Although most genealogists would be hard-pressed to prove it, Michael Johnston and Tom Scholz could very well be related. Scholz, for those too young to remember (or too old to bother), was the M.I.T. grad student and leader of the quintessentially '70s fivesome Boston, whose self-titled first effort hit the Top 5 in 1976, produced still-popular classic rock radio staples like "Long Time" and "More than a Feeling," and went on to become the biggest-selling rock debut in history. The equally successful follow-on, 1978's Don't Look Back, claimed the top spot on the album charts, sent its title cut into the Top 5 and pulled down platinum record honors within weeks of its release.

Nineteen years later, and the distance between Boston, Massachusetts, and Tifton, Georgia, away, Michael Johnston and his bandmates in The Smalltown Poets have followed an eerily similar career arc to Scholz's. The Poets' self-named 1997 debut became the most successful first album ever by a Christian group and generated no less than six Top 20 hits. Following a mere nine months behind the freshman project, Listen Closely vaulted an additional three entries into the Top 20 and pulled down even more glowing critical praise. But, like Scholz, who took nearly eight years to follow Don't Look Back with the disappointing Third Stage effort and has recorded only sporadically since, Johnston's ever-thinning STP herd spent a long two and a half years on their third project, the largely uneven Third Verse, and an additional four years before turning out the latest offering.

Encouragingly, the opening strains of It's Later Than It's Ever Been find Johnston, the lone remaining original Poet, and his newly-assembled outfit returning to top form. The infectious leadoff track, "The Truth Is Out," blends crisp acoustic guitars, a lively melody and Johnston's characteristically melancholy-tinged voice into an irresistible three-and-a-half-minute musical cocktail. The follow-on cut, "Show Me Who You Are," with its jangling guitar lines and crunchy modern pop/rock textures continues the winning streak, coming across as a slightly harder-edged "Prophet, Priest and King." And the likewise vigorous "Upside Down" bookends the stellar opening three-song salvo with Johnston's imposing lyrical eloquence and razor-sharp insight (She likes to have me by her side/ I guess I look good over her shoulder/ Immune to gravity/ I can't seem to pull her closer).

From that point on, the results vary. "There on the Sun" is a slightly less catchy cousin to the first three songs. "Here" features some fairly sublime electric guitar work. And the rootsy, hard-rocking "A New Beginning" hints at a latent Stonsian bent that the Poet cooperative would do well to explore further. By and large though, the remainder of the album is a mostly nondescript affair. In its defense, Later does best the Third Verse record and features no shortage of cuts that would sit well on Top 40 radio. But, with Johnston's imposing songwriting skills and four years between albums, one can't help but feel a bit disappointed. While the Later project is proficiently played and produced, any new release from Johnston & Co. is certainly cause for celebration, longtime listeners will likely cast a wistful backwards glance at the debut and sophomore records, which remain daunting high-water marks that Johnston and his cohorts still struggle mightily to equal.

3 tocks