The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998/Terry Scott Taylor
    Terry Scott Taylor — John Wayne cover

    Terry Scott Taylor

    John Wayne

    (1998)

    Reviewed by Steven S. Baldwin

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label KMG RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth1998
    alternative rockpop rockpower pop

    Virtually every so-called "Christian alternative modern rock" band owes a hearty debt to the granddaddy of ACM, Terry Taylor. After all, when he and his band, Daniel Amos, traded in their cowboy hats and cowpoke tunes for 3-D glasses and smart New Wave pop ditties back in the late seventies, "Christian Music" embarked on a curious, much needed path, raising the creative bar for all to follow. Terry Taylor is the pioneer that blazed the trail. A mighty master of sonic distortion; a giant among his petite peers (and humble, too); a bona fide force of fury for the cause of good; (I'll stop now). When all these new, young upstart bands are done kissing his feet, they ought to check out his latest album, John Wayne, to see how it's done. Their forefather is still making music a step ahead, with hits galore, and a big fat booty of wisdom besides.

    John Wayne finds Taylor doing what he has always done best: creating a musically eclectic album of thought-provoking and faith-inspiring content. It is his umpteenth album in a career spanning 20 plus years as the main man behind such bands as Daniel Amos and The Swirling Eddies, and a principal member of the Lost Dogs. However, it is only the fourth to bear his name as a solo album. He'd be the first to tell you that his albums are never really solo efforts, however. Here he shares the stage with an impressive host of friends, including his Lost Dogs pals--Mike Roe on guitars, Derri Daugherty on guitars, and Gene Eugene on keyboards--as well as Daniel Amos members Tim Chandler on bass and Ed McTaggart on drums. Additionally, former Prayer Chain member Andy Prickett grinds some guitar parts, the ubiquitous Phil Madeira adds keyboards, accordion, and lap steel, and Burleigh Drummond plays some percussion. Together they generate a tight, textured sound with great energy and enthusiasm.

    Those familiar with Taylor's previous solo albums may be surprised to find that this one has less in common musically with the mellower fare of Knowledge and Innocence or Briefing for the Ascent. It certainly has more straight-forward lyrical content than the brilliantly absurd bits from Neverhood Songs. In fact, John Wayne has much more in common with recent Daniel Amos offerings. He has effectively combined a sound that is most reminiscent of Bibleland, Songs of the Heart and the best bits from Kalhoun. The result is an infectiously furious, gutsy rock band sound with jangly guitars, slippery bass, big beats, instantly memorable melodies, rich harmonies, and lots of appropriately noisy bits. Although somewhat similar in overall orchestration, none of the songs sound the same, and every one of them is catchier than striped bass in a fish breeding pond (meaning that you won't be able to stop singin' along).

    Taylor has taken his inspiration from close to home, with songs centering on Orange County, John "The Duke" Wayne, and the John Wayne International Airport. Don't be fooled, however, by this clever veneer. Every song is actually an opportunity for Taylor to sing his signature songs of overcoming life's difficulties through the light of love, faith, hope, and strident dependence on our Great God of Grace. He is at his introspective best on this collection. For example, "Mr. Flutter" finds Taylor as honest, crafty, and accessible as ever:

    Well, I'm tryin' to write a song
    But I don't have the words
    And my kids need a doctor
    But I'm not insured
    And my wife she looks pale
    She got the check in the mail
    And it's not the amount
    We were thinking about
    I got a friend on high
    And he feels my pain
    But I still got this dust
    Flowin' through my veins
    And I want to have faith
    And I want to know grace
    But it's hard to break through
    When the rent's overdue.

    Later, in a throwback to his country-roots days in "Ten Gallon Hat," Taylor offers his trademark brand of humor and wit in a song that reminds his avid fans to accept him as both saint and sinner. This tension of being both beloved of God and wading in the nasty mud this side of heaven is a theme that carries through much of this album, and finds its most beautiful fruition in the album's last track. "You Lay Down" accurately and breathtakingly depicts Jesus as accepting us despite our evil inclination. One of the best, most effective, engaging, and captivating songs he has ever penned, "You Lay Down" is right up there with "My Hand to God" as a new hymn worth hearing.

    You didn't say a word when we accused you
    You did not fight back when we scarred and bruised you
    When hate was crowned king your love never diminished
    You stood meek as a lamb there without blemish
    And we laughed when you cried out: "It is finished"
    So you lay down and I'll step upon your back
    Up high enough, above the fence, to see all the way to glory land.

    More could be said about this ingenious album which time may title his Darn Floor, Big Bite for the nineties, but why spoil all the Tayloresque surprises. If nothing else, this album closes the case on whether or not Taylor has still got it. John Wayne approaches his best work, with its intimate, appealing, and witty window into the soul of one who wrestles with God. God must let Taylor win a few of those matches, just because he loves him so dearly, and this album is your ringside ticket for the bout.

    5 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    7ball #21Reviewed by Brian Quincy NewcombAs icons come and go, there's probably no better metaphorical image for the spiritual and literal terra firma that is Orange County, Southern California--the conservative Christian stronghold and creative hotbed for most Christian rock and alternative music--than that of John Wayne, the gun-toting movie star, pilgrim in a strange land and model for self-reliant individualism gone awry. On John…The Phantom Tollbooth 1998Reviewed by James StewartCountry, New Wave, alternative rock, computer game soundtracks, satirical punk... Terry Taylor has been around several musical blocks over the past two decades. Now seemingly more settled with his position at KMG Records, this recording provides the listener with a sound which shows influences from all his previous work. The album opens darkly. The string-section backing for "Writer's Block" has…

    Similar sounding releases

    2004The ObsoletesIs This Progress?1996Lost DogsGreen Room Serenade, Part One1994R.E.M.Monster1998The LemonheadsThe Best of the Lemonheads: The Atlantic Years1997All Star UnitedAll Star United2004Tim LeeNo Discretion

    More from Terry Scott Taylor

    1998Neverhood Songs2000Avocado Faultline1999Glimpses of Grace

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1998

    1998Lisa Gerrard / Pieter BourkeDuality1997Paupers FieldVoice1998LugsoleProblems of Involvement1998Margaret BeckerFalling Forward1998MICCrazy World1998The WaterboysThe Live Adventures of The Waterboys