The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    HM Magazine #109/The Prisoners Dilemma
    The Prisoners Dilemma — Handshakes, Hello and Goodbye cover

    The Prisoners Dilemma

    Handshakes, Hello and Goodbye

    (2004)

    Reviewed by David Stagg

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Indianola RecordsHM Magazine #109September/October 2004
    emoexperimentalmetalcorepost-hardcore

    Expect to hear a lot about The Prisoners Dilemma—and for good reason. This Anaheim-based band has put together one of the most eclectic, melee attacks of a release and it begs to be heard. On the opening track "A Three Second Excerpt," the band traverses emo to metal to piano ballad in five minutes—and does it really, really well. The experimental and closing track to the record, "The Surrendering," sounds like it could be Phantom of the Opera interlude music or the soundtrack to a horror movie. The only downfall of the CD is that it's short. Give us more: It's wonderful listening to a CD where you have no idea what the band is going to throw at you next, and The Prisoners Dilemma does exactly this.

    Editors' ratings — Doug 4/5, David 3/5

    Other coverage for this album

    Decapolis May 2004Reviewed by Justin BrinkerIt seems like a lot of independent record labels find that artist that will put them on the map, the artist that will finally give the label the recognition they deserve. For Victory Records it was Thursday and then Taking Back Sunday. For Tooth and Nail Records it was MxPx and The Juliana Theory. Other labels like Lookout Records discovered Green Day, Sub Pop brought us Nirvana, Vagrant gave us…

    Similar sounding releases

    2005A Day to RememberAnd Their Name Was Treason2003AnadivineAnadivine2003SilversteinWhen Broken is Easily Fixed2005Chasing VictoryI Call This Abandonment2005ChiodosAll's Well That Ends Well2003The Hurt ProcessDrive By Monologue

    Also in HM Magazine #109

    2004Royal AnguishThe Chronicles of Autumn Sorrow200412 StonesPotter's Field2004The MyriadThe Myriad2004Bloodlined CalligraphyThe Beginning of the End2004Joy ElectricHello, Mannequin2003AdiosThe Ropes