The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2002/Traindodge
    Traindodge — On a Lake of Dead Trees cover

    Traindodge

    On a Lake of Dead Trees

    (2001)

    Reviewed by Dan Singleton

    DiscogsBandcampApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Ascetic Records / No Karma RecordingsThe Phantom Tollbooth2002
    math rockpost-hardcoreprogressive rock

    If Albert Einstein were alive today, Traindodge's On a Lake of Dead Trees is the album he would be relaxing to. It is a rare feat--a kind you can engage and bang your head to or just sit back and let it massage your mind.

    On a Lake of Dead Trees is exactly what one expects from Traindodge--bass-driven math-rock constructions, furious strumming, infinite sustains, pleading vocals and cymbal-heavy drumming. This album, however, represents the Norman, Okla., band's dissertation from the Robert Fripp School of Songwriting. Fewer and fewer songs contain observable verse-chorus distinctions, as Traindodge is choosing more frequently to intersperse words designed to invoke the feel of the song rather than just make statements.

    More progressive than ever, Traindodge takes this opportunity to place more sonic diversity within a single track than most artists have on an entire album (or even their careers in some cases). Somehow they manage this while still retaining the song's feel all the way through. A great example of this is "Curtain Call," which features a number of slow-downs, build-ups, and subtle combinations and recombinations of the instruments, alternating punctuation with strumming so fast it nearly turns into emo. Heck, what am I saying? Every song on this album is like that! But that's just the stylistic unity you find in Traindodge. Each song still contributes its own unique vibe.

    "Curtain Call" does, however, seem to have the least abstruse lyrics:

    I'm obliged to ask you
    Because we are not going the same way
    It's this introduction in the final stage
    We are not going the same way.

    My take is that it's about a conversationally challenged couple, one of whom realizes it's time to break it off. But then Traindodge lyricist Jason Smith tries to write so the listener can pull out a number of interpretations (See interview this issue). Most of the other lyrics are so recondite and poetic that I can't even attempt an interpretation. Not that this is bad. Even within a verse, one word might be several bars away from the next, multiplying its evocative value. Truly some innovative work being done by these guys.

    On a Lake of Dead Trees is an album worth getting. If there's any reason for complaint, it's that most of these songs (taken individually) would have fit perfectly on their last full album, About Tomorrow's Mileage. But as good as that album was, I'm not complaining.

    4.5 tocks

    Similar sounding releases

    2004Kill VeronaTrauma1999StavesacreSpeakeasy1999ElliottIf They Do2002The Color RedClear2002Project 86Truthless Heroes2001NarcissusBecoming Leviathan

    More from Traindodge

    2005Under Black Sails

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2002

    2002Eamonn CoyneThrough the Round Window2002Neil YoungAre You Passionate?2002Various ArtistsThe Wonderful Cross2002Mary's DenSongs from the Living Room2002Various ArtistsBlisscent I2002Freddie BrunoThe Ballpoint Composer