The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1999/Eternal Decision
    Eternal Decision — Ghost in the Machine cover

    Eternal Decision

    Ghost in the Machine

    (1999)

    Reviewed by Josh Spencer

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Godfather RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth1999
    groove metalheavy metalthrash metal

    This sophomore effort by former Metallica rip-offs Eternal Decision is a textbook lesson in downtuned riffery. There's the chug. The gallop pick. The stop-and-go. The stutter. The building mosh. The buzzing groove. The march of doom. The hammer. If you've listened to heavy music much at all, you've heard them countless times. Which makes Ghost in the Machine enjoyable in a very base, low brain activity way. Though they at least had signs of potential with their first copycat effort, this is completely unchallenging and uncreative...and as a result, most Christian metalheads should be happy with it.

    For the most part, they've left behind the proto '80s thrash and dumbed down their sound to modern groove metal, adding some very slight and cheap-sounding industrial effects. They have progressed a bit by working in some mellow sections and hooks, but the amateurishness of it all holds them back. The Metallica and Pantera imitation is far less pronounced, though a hint of Ride the Lightning-ish Hetfield grit remains in the vocals. Ghost in the Machine is actually an almost identical musical progression to that of the Jesus Freaks a few years back. Except rather than the sludge production that ruined that band's second production, Eternal Decision stick with their odd, 2-dimensional warehouse clankiness.

    The mediocre music is paralleled by simple lyrics that make no effort at sophistication or subtlety. The title track is a metaphor for sin and how we've been set free. The anthemic, hooky chorus of "Through this Pain" groans "I need you now/to help me with this pain inside." Most of the lyrics deal with addiction; and the struggle between the old man and the new, flesh and spirit, now and eternity. Eternal Decision is all about their name, and they're thankful for the love and strength that flows from God once you make that call. Too bad limited funds and a lack of musical innovation will probably keep them from ever communicating that to more than a few fist-pumping headbangers.

    Other coverage for this album

    Art for the Ears 2000Reviewed by Marco PovervestOkay, skip the first track. It's just a silly intro. The first song, Breaking, comes next. It shows that Eternal Decision hasn't been sitting idle since the titleless album. That record featured vocals that sounded like an imitation of Metallica's James Hetfield. On this new one that's not so evident anymore. The music itself has evolved into something more mature. Still there's a slight…HM Magazine #79Reviewed by David BixlerWell, after having heard rumors that these guys had broken up, here they come with a brand new CD. It seems like they decided to shrug off most of the Metallica soundscapes that dominated their first disc. What ensues is some seriously crunchy, very tightly played, thrashy heavy metal. Though perhaps nothing completely new-sounding, this CD sounds very good, with great song-writing and a very…

    Similar sounding releases

    2001MortificationThe Silver Cord Is Severed2002SanctificaNegative B2005Mercury SwitchTime to Shine2003ZaoLegendary1999ParamaeciumA Time to Mourn2005Living SacrificeIn Memoriam

    More from Eternal Decision

    [title unknown]1996Eternal Decision

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1999

    1999Katharine WhalenJazz Squad1999The BlamedForever1998Various ArtistsJumping in the House of God III1998FFHI Want to Be Like You1999Mark BrineAmerican Bleak House1998Autumn WarSix-Song Demo