The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    ReAL Magazine 1999/Hangnail
    Hangnail — Hangnail cover

    Hangnail

    Hangnail

    (1999)

    Reviewed by Kevin D. Hendricks

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label BEC RecordingsReAL Magazine1999
    heavy metalpop punkpunkskate punk

    Hangnail is a four piece punk band from southern Wisconsin. They're a young band and from what I can tell, completely unheard of. But BEC Records usually knows what they're doing, and I think they discovered a talented bunch with Hangnail.

    Their self titled debut CD isn't exactly Grammy material. It probably won't turn too many heads. But you have to respect it for what it is. High school punk bands are a dime a dozen, very few of them can play well, let alone write anything well, and quality production is a foreign concept. Local punk bands usually get by with their live shows and selling substandard tapes and CDs to satisfy their local public until the next concert. Hangnail manages to rise above the local scene and begins to grasp some of what it takes to be a national success.

    Musically the album is impressive for a punk band. Two guitars give them a lot of freedom to experiment and make some interesting sounds. When they take their time with intros and bridges it's usually a worthy effort. Lyrically Hangnail holds their own. I don't think their lyrics are spectacular, but they do cover substantial ground. Subjects include abortion, God's love, anger, hypocrisy, and the punk favorite, being a band ("It all started out with a stupid name in eighth grade / we never thought it would amount to much."). Punk music is rarely impressive vocally, and Hangnail hardly differs here. The vocals are average at best, but the one redeeming quality is their liberal use of harmonies. Yeah, harmonies, in punk rock. What a concept. A number of their choruses are charged with strong backing vocals and sometimes even harmonies. It adds a certain strength and intensity to the music. Finally, Hangnail's production is top notch. I wouldn't expect anything less from BEC, but for a punk band it's nice to have a clean, polished sound for once.

    'Double Standard' is a good example of their musical talent with its one-minute-plus intro. 'Worthless' urges us to "hold the wealth of the world / loosely in the palm of our hands," and ads a unique choir type chorus at the end. My favorite song has to be 'Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Your Anger.' The chorus is the title line repeated four times--borderline repetitive--but their use of harmonies redeems the song and makes it stick in my head in a way I love.

    All in all Hangnail is pretty fun punk band. It's not ground breaking music or the best album of the year. But if you like punk music it's worth your time. The foursome reminds me of an early MxPx and I'll be keeping an eye on them in the future.

    Other coverage for this album

    HM Magazine #81Reviewed by David M. PoggeWhile their name may suggest nerve-wracking anguish and irritation, Hangnail deliver quite the opposite with their soothing blend of quality pop pleasure for your well tuned listening ears. As is becoming the trend for the Brandon Ebel / Tooth & Nail empire, this album is melodic punk rock through and through. Luckily, for all of us who are growing weary of the recent excess of this genre,…Decapolis 2000Reviewed by ConradThis is pretty much an MxPx based pop-punk album. If you put a little more Slick Shoes guitar in there with vocals that don't really stand out a whole lot this is what you would have. The main aspect that I thought was good about this band was the guitarist - he was great. Unfortunately the songs didn't utilize his talents enough for my taste. If there were more guitar work many of the songs…Decapolis 2000Reviewed by Tom BastianSomebody has to tell me, what is the deciding factor between if a band gets put on BEC or Tooth and Nail Records? Why even have the two separate labels, this band could have easily been on Tooth and Nail with the other 10 new punk rock bands they just signed. I guess maybe it's something I will never really understand. I have noticed that the BEC bands seem to be more spiritual in their lyrical…Decapolis 2000Reviewed by TimGeez, could they be any more normal. My girlfriend hated this so much she made me take it out of the tape player until she got out of the car. There is absolutely nothing special about this cd. At the same time, it was so bland that I can't remember anything to criticize. It just wasn't interesting. CThe Phantom Tollbooth 2000Reviewed by Josh SpencerHangnail is one of those punk bands that sound best as a single track on a compilation. They're yet another variety of the MxPx guy vocal/pop punk style that's so popular with the youngsters. Lots of "Whoa-oh-oh" choruses combined with tight, very competent rhythms. Their trick in the bag is their lead guitarist, but they only let him out on a couple of tracks--"Friendly Advice," with its '80s…Bandoppler 1999Reviewed by Earl CampbellOut went Value Pac, enter the pop-punk melodies of Hangnail from Wisconsin. With refined, mature vocals and obvious musical talent, they cruise through their self-titled debut full-length - an album that exudes spit-polished production value. More emphasis on the pop, but all the basic elements of punk rock are present: power chords, masked metal riffs, and speedy breakdowns. Only one thing…

    Similar sounding releases

    2002The ReactionThe Reaction1999The AtarisBlue Skies...Broken Hearts...Next 12 Exits2000Ghoti HookTwo Years to Never2004The VandalsHollywood Potato Chip2002Authority ZeroA Passage in Time2000The DealYesterday, Today & Forever

    More from Hangnail

    2003Transparent2001Facing Changes2001The Acoustic EPHangnail '98

    Also in ReAL Magazine 1999

    1999Various ArtistsHappy Christmas Vol. 21998FonoGoesaroundcomesaround1999Ginny OwensWithout Condition1999Room Full of WaltersEl Grande1999Geoff MooreGeoff Moore1999100 Portraits / WaterdeepEnter the Worship Circle